Differences between qualified personal and professional electronic signatures
A qualified electronic signature (QES) regardless of whether it is a personal or professional signature has the same legal force as a handwritten signature.
It can act „universally” - as personal signature - or „corporate”-as professional/service signature assigned to a representative in the organization. It is still a signature particular person, but the scope of the data in the certificate and the context of use are different.
Here are the main differences between the two signature functions: technique, law, applications, costs and practical tips from podpisano.pl.
Technical differences: release, carriers, identification
How does one make out?
- Personal (universal) - verification of the identity of the person only (proof/passport).
- Professional (business) - in addition to the identity of the person must be confirmed company data i empowerment (e.g., copy of KRS/CEIDG, NIP/REGON, possibly power of attorney, function/position document).
What it works on
- Both types can be spent on crypto/USB card (e.g. Certum Mini) albo jako cloud/mobile signature (e.g. SimplySign). Wybór to kwestia wygody i polityki organizacji – power and safety standards are the same.
What the certificate contains
- Personal: Data of the person (first name, last name; sometimes PESEL/NIP of the entrepreneur).
- Professional: person's data + organization data (name, address, NIP, REGON; often function/position). With this from certificate immediately follows, who and what entity they represent.
Legal differences: ownership and liability
- Certificate is always named - Assigned to a person. It is this person who makes the statement of intent and is responsible for the use of the signature (PIN/password protection, no sharing).
- Service signature does not become „company property.” The company can finance it and manage the life cycle (procedures, cancellation), but formally signs the man.
- Certificate with company details does not convert e-signature into „organization signature” (that's what it's for qualified electronic seal). He reveals the context - I sign as representative of the entity in question.
Business applications: when personal, when professional?
Personal signature (universal)
- Universal „for everything”: official matters (US, Social Security, e-KRS), contracts, offers, letters.
- Ideal for JDG - the same person is a company, it is not necessary to add the data of the organization in the certificate.
- It also works in companies - you can sign company documents with it, according to the representation rules or on the basis of powers of attorney.
- Pros: flexibility, one certificate for multiple roles/entities.
- Minuses: The recipient does not always see right away, on whose behalf the signer acts (you have to rely on context/authorization).
Professional (business/company) signature
- When it counts immediate identification of the company in the certificate (contracts, tender offers, B2B/B2G correspondence, reports).
- Often used by management/executives/lawyers And in administration (public functions).
- Tender specifications sometimes require a certificate with company data.
- Pros: Clear context of representation, fewer additions/attachments.
- Limitations: we use only to the affairs of this company; when changing jobs - the certificate should be cancel and issue a new one at the new employer.
Cost: what really makes a difference?
- Status (personal vs business) in itself is not a price category. We pay for same type of qualified certificate and selected technical form.
- The cost is mainly influenced by: carrier (card/USB vs cloud), shelf life (1/2/3 years), method of verification (stationary/remote, express mode, commute).
- The Certum to QES packages include access to the following as standard. qualified time stamp. In practice, with the SimplySign and Certum Mini in the models offered by podpisano.pl, you have a Up to 5,000 time stamps per month in price - that's the only „limit” you might be interested in operationally (and rarely a barrier).
- Who pays? In the service model, usually employer. In the personal - the employer or the person himself (unless he counts as a business expense).
Why do employers prefer business QES for employees?
- Clear representation - The company's name and NIP in the certificate tell contractors and authorities everything without further explanation.
- Order and security - Holder records, training, PIN/PUK policies, loss procedures, quick cancellation After a change of position/departure.
- Separation of roles - private affairs by private QES, corporate affairs by corporate QES
- Formal requirements - tenders, corporate regulations, public functions; where the „firmness” of the certificate speeds up procedures.
- Scalability and efficiency - Mass signatures in HR/finance, remote working, uniform set of tools (e.g., SimplySign + proCertum SmartSign/Certum Mini), simpler IT support.
A brief comparison
Feature | QES personal (universal) | QES professional (business) |
Data in the certificate | Person (first name, last name; opc. PESEL/NIP) | Person + company (name, NIP/REGON, opc. function) |
Context of use | Private, JDG, also in the company | Exclusively matters of a particular company |
Issue | Only verification of the person | Verification of the person i entity + empowerment |
Carrier | Card/USB (e.g., Certum Mini) or cloud (SimplySign) | Idly |
Legal power | Equivalent to a handwritten signature | Equivalent to a handwritten signature |
Change of job | No impact | The certificate should be revoked |
Cost | As for the selected form/period | Same price model |
Timestamp | In practice, to 5000/month. in podpisano.pl packages | In practice, to 5000/month. in podpisano.pl packages |
What information can be included on a professional signature?
- Name(s)
- Company Name,
- NIP or KRS or Regon or all three together
- Position
- Academic titles
- Profession, e.g.: lawyer, surveyor. etc.
However, moderation should be kept in mind in all this. At our disposal we have only 64 characters (including spaces).
The most common questions
Can I use my business signature privately?
It shouldn't. The certificate contains the company's data and can be misleading about representation. Use a personal QES for private matters.
What after the termination of the employment relationship if the signature was financed by the company?
At the certificate with company data - the employer should cancel certificate. At the certificate personal - the decision depends on the findings; the company can demand the return of the carrier and request cancellation, but the certificate itself remains valid can be used until the end of its validity period.
Is a business signature a „company signature”?
No. It is always signed by a person. If you need a purely organizational „signature” (without a person), it is used for this purpose qualified electronic seal.
Is personal „inferior” in court/office?
No. Both are QES - they have identical legal force. The difference is clarity of representation and convenience in corporate processes.
Our recommendations
- For boards of directors, proxies, sales/procurement departments: QES professional with company data - fewer questions on the part of contractors and faster in procedures.
- For JDG, consultants working with multiple entities, people in multiple positions or functions: QES personal (universal) - maximum flexibility.
- Carrier: if mobility and remote working – SimplySign (cloud); if you prefer the equipment in your hand -. Certum Mini (card/USB).
- Always add a qualified timestamp - is standard in our packages (up to 5000/month) and the basis for long-term verifiability.
Want to select a variant for your company's processes? Contact us, at podpisano.pl - we will select the configuration (number of licenses, roles), train users.
In conclusion ...
- Legal power - same.
- Differences - w certificate data i context of use.
- Service - Clear representation of the company, control and compliance.
- Personal - flexibility of roles and actors.
- Costs - determined mainly by the carrier, period and method of verification, rather than the status of the certificate.
- Best practices - Timestamp, security policies, holder registry, quick overrides.
Products we recommend at podpisano.pl
- SimplySign (QES in the cloud) - Mobility, immediate deployment, convenient field and remote validation.
- Certum Mini (card/USB + proCertum SmartSign) - Control of devices on stations, offline scenarios, signature + timestamp added on the spot or after returning to the network.
If you need a checklist of documents for the issuance of a professional signature for the team (management, attorneys, administration), let us know - we will send a ready-made template and help you go through the process „step by step”.
Qualified signatures SimplySign and Certum Mini
If you have any concerns or questions, please contact us
We will answer your questions, find a date that suits you and an advisor in Gdansk, Gdynia, Krakow, Warsaw or Wroclaw.
You can also write an email from us [email protected].